Safety: burning magnesium, silver nitrate and flames are for a teacher or a supervised school lab only. Wear eye protection; never look straight at burning magnesium.
In a physical change a substance changes its shape, size or state but stays the same substance: ice, water and steam are all H₂O. In a chemical change the atoms are rearranged into new substances, like rust from iron and oxygen. In both, no atoms are made or lost, so mass is conserved.
These clues suggest that a new substance has been made. One clue on its own can trick you, so look for several, and ask: is there a new substance, and can I easily get the old one back?
A new color that is not just mixing paints: iron turning orange-brown as it rusts, a cut apple going brown.
Trick: mixing blue and yellow paint makes green without a reaction.
Fizzing when baking soda meets vinegar (carbon dioxide), or bubbles of hydrogen when a metal reacts with acid.
Trick: boiling water also bubbles, but the gas is just steam.
Two clear solutions make a cloudy solid, like silver chloride or the scum from soap in hard water.
Trick: salt crystals appearing as water evaporates is physical.
The mixture gets hot (burning, hand warmers) or cold (baking soda and vinegar, citric acid and baking soda) by itself.
Trick: melting and dissolving can take in heat too.
Flames, fireworks, burning magnesium, glow sticks.
Trick: a light bulb glows without making a new substance.
Milk going sour, food cooking or burning, rotten eggs.
Trick: perfume spreading is just particles moving.
In any change, atoms are not made or destroyed, so the total mass stays the same. But a balance only weighs what is on it. The balance is now inside the virtual lab: press ⚖️ Weigh it, click each set-up (Open beaker, Sealed bottle + balloon, Burning magnesium, Melting ice (closed)), press ▶ Start and explain the reading. Then try 🔍 Zoom into rust.
Masses are worked out from the equations: 2.00 g of baking soda with excess vinegar makes about 1.05 g of carbon dioxide; 0.24 g of magnesium makes about 0.40 g of magnesium oxide.
| Physical change | Chemical change | |
|---|---|---|
| New substance? | No: same particles | Yes: atoms rearranged into new particles |
| What changes | shape, size, state, arrangement or mixing | composition: the bonds between atoms |
| Reversing it | often easy (freeze, evaporate, filter, use a magnet) | usually hard; needs another chemical reaction |
| Energy | heat taken in or given out when the state changes | often heat or light given out or taken in |
| Mass | conserved | conserved (count any gases that escape or join) |
| Examples | melting ice, boiling water, dissolving salt, tearing paper, separating iron from sand | burning, rusting, cooking an egg, baking soda + vinegar, a precipitate forming |
Burning paper: cellulose + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water (C₆H₁₀O₅ + 6O₂ → 6CO₂ + 5H₂O for each sugar unit; real burning also makes ash and smoke). Baking soda + vinegar: NaHCO₃ + CH₃COOH → CH₃COONa + H₂O + CO₂. Silver nitrate + salt water: AgNO₃(aq) + NaCl(aq) → AgCl(s) + NaNO₃(aq).
Limiting reactant: 50 mL of vinegar with 5% acetic acid holds 2.50 g (0.0416 mol) of acetic acid, enough for 3.50 g of baking soda. Add more baking soda and the extra stays as white powder: the vinegar runs out first. Up to that point, more baking soda makes more CO₂ and a bigger temperature drop.
Real rust is hydrated iron(III) oxide (Fe₂O₃·nH₂O): water joins too, so a real rusty nail gains even more mass than the dry iron oxide in the zoom.
The baking soda and vinegar mixture gets colder because the reaction takes in heat: about +31 kJ per mole, estimated from standard enthalpies of formation. For 2.00 g in 50 mL that is about 3.6 °C on paper; a real beaker cools by a little less because it also warms from the room.
Model notes: the particle pictures show a few molecules; burning paper is one sugar unit of cellulose; sand is drawn as SiO₂ units, though real sand is a giant network; the cooked egg shows protein chains, not atoms. In the 3D view the ball sizes follow covalent radii, drawn smaller than real so that the bonds show.
One question at a time: pick an answer to see right away if you are right and why, then go on to the next one. New questions picks another set.
Tap a change, then tap the box it belongs in. Check when all twelve are placed.
The diagram you label in a test: a chemical reaction drawn with particles (reactants, products, atoms, molecules and bonds), the signs of a chemical change, and a physical change. Switch between the labeled diagram, a blank one to test your memory, and a quiz where you place each label yourself. You can also download both versions or print a label worksheet.
Tap a word, then tap the numbered box it belongs to (on the diagram or in the list below). Tap a filled box to take the word back. On a phone, swipe the diagram sideways to see every number.
A 45-minute lesson. Hook: on the projector (Full screen) run Boiling water and then Baking soda + vinegar. Both bubble: which one makes a new substance? Pairs then predict and run all 11 experiments and fill in table A of the worksheet. Weigh it and Zoom into rust bring in conservation of mass; the six missions guide them (predict → test → explain).
The balance readings come from the balanced equations (2.00 g of baking soda gives about 1.05 g of CO₂; 0.24 g of magnesium gives about 0.40 g of magnesium oxide; 0.70 g of rusting iron takes about 0.30 g of oxygen). The temperatures are worked out from the heat of each change (salt: +3.87 kJ/mol; baking soda + vinegar: about +31 kJ/mol, estimated from standard enthalpies of formation); real classroom results vary by a degree or so. Rusting is shown as dry iron oxide; real rust also holds water.
Real-lab safety: burning magnesium, silver nitrate and flames are for a teacher or a supervised school lab only. Wear eye protection; silver nitrate stains skin and can damage eyes; never look straight at burning magnesium.
Misconceptions to target: bubbles always mean a chemical change; dissolving destroys the salt; irreversible means chemical; burning destroys mass; rust is lighter than iron. Vocabulary: physical change, chemical change, substance, property, reactant, product, precipitate, conservation of mass, particle, atom, molecule.
Standards: NGSS 5-PS1-2 (mass is conserved), 5-PS1-4 (mixing makes new substances?), MS-PS1-2 (properties before and after), MS-PS1-5 (atoms conserved) · KS2 / KS3 chemistry
| Time | Step | What students do | Go to |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 min | Hook | Run Boiling water and Baking soda + vinegar: which bubbles are a new gas? | Virtual lab |
| 15 min | Explore | Predict and run all 11 experiments; worksheet part A | Virtual lab |
| 10 min | Weigh it | Open beaker vs sealed bottle, burning magnesium; worksheet part B | Virtual lab |
| 5 min | Zoom into rust | Vote, then let the nail rust; worksheet part C | Virtual lab |
| 5 min | Sort | Sort 12 everyday changes | Sort the changes |
| 5 min | Exit ticket | Quiz round or worksheet question 5 (CER) | Quiz |
Worksheet: a print-out for students and a separate answer key page for the teacher (opens the print dialog; choose "Save as PDF" to keep a file).
A physical change alters the form, size or state of a substance but not what it is made of (ice melting). A chemical change makes one or more new substances with new properties (wood burning).
Key takeaway: same substance = physical; new substance = chemical.A color change, gas or bubbles, a solid (precipitate) forming, a temperature change, and light; a new smell is a sixth. One sign alone is not proof: boiling water bubbles but is a physical change.
Key takeaway: color, gas, precipitate, temperature, light (and smell).Physical. The molecules are H₂O before and after; they just move more freely in the liquid. The ice stays at 0 °C while it melts, and freezing the water gives ice back.
Key takeaway: melting is physical.At school level it is a physical change: no new substance is made, and you get the salt back by evaporating the water. (Salt breaks up into ions as it dissolves, but they are the same ions that were in the crystal.)
Key takeaway: dissolving is physical: evaporate to get it back.No. The bubbles are water vapor, the same H₂O molecules spread far apart. Cool the steam and it condenses back into water. The bubbles in baking soda and vinegar are different: they are a new gas, carbon dioxide.
Key takeaway: boiling is physical; the bubbles are still water.Yes. Heat makes the egg proteins unfold and join together with new bonds, so the clear egg white turns white and solid, and cooling it does not make it raw again.
Key takeaway: cooking an egg is chemical.The wood reacts with oxygen to make carbon dioxide and water vapor, which escape into the air, leaving light ash. If you could collect all the gases, the total mass of the products would equal the mass of the wood plus the oxygen used.
Key takeaway: mass escapes as gas; it is not destroyed.Yes. Rust is iron oxide: oxygen atoms from the air (and water) join the iron atoms. When 0.70 g of iron turns into iron oxide, about 0.30 g of oxygen joins it, so the nail and its rust weigh more than the iron did.
Key takeaway: rust = iron + oxygen, so it is heavier.Bonds between atoms break and new bonds form, so the atoms join up in new combinations. The number of each kind of atom stays the same, which is why mass is conserved and equations must balance.
Key takeaway: atoms are rearranged, not created or destroyed.Yes. Speed does not decide it: iron reacts with oxygen and water to make hydrated iron(III) oxide, a new substance that is flaky, orange-brown and weaker than iron.
Key takeaway: slow changes can still be chemical.