← SciSim / Chemistry

Atomic Structure Lab: Gold Foil, Protons, Neutrons, Electrons, Isotopes & Bohr Models

⚛️ Grades 7–10 (NGSS MS-PS1-1; HS-PS1-1, HS-PS1-8 intro) + AP extension in “Going further”. Shells and valence electrons are grade 8–10 content.
An atom is mostly empty space around a tiny, dense nucleus of protons and neutrons; the electrons are found around it at different energy levels. The number of protons decides the element, neutrons make isotopes and electrons make ions. Zoom in, repeat Rutherford’s gold foil experiment, read isotope notation, find average atomic mass and fill Bohr shells in 8 missions.
🎯 Missions 0 / 8For teachers

🔍 Mission 1 · How Small Is an Atom? Grades 7–10 · MS-PS1-1

Zoom from a sugar cube down to a single gold atom and its nucleus. Each step shows the real size, the power of ten and a scale bar. Then predict the answers to 3 questions and check them with the numbers. Mission: all 3 answered, at least 2 right on the first try.

Size

Stadium analogy. If an atom were as wide as a 100 m stadium, the nucleus would be a bead only a few millimeters across on the center spot (gold: about 5 mm; hydrogen: about 2 mm). The electrons are found far out in the stands. Everything in between is empty space, yet the bead holds more than 99.9 % of the mass.

Answered: 0 / 3 · right on the first try: 0

Sizes: grain of table salt about 0.5 mm; human hair about 80 µm wide; a typical animal cell 10–20 µm; many viruses about 100 nm; a gold atom 0.29 nm across (radius 0.144 nm); a gold nucleus about 14 fm (1.4 × 10⁻¹⁴ m). 1 nm = 10⁻⁹ m. An atom has no hard edge, so “size” means the usual distance between atom centers.

✨ Mission 2 · The Gold Foil Experiment Grades 7–10 · MS-PS1-1, HS-PS1-1

In 1909 Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, working with Ernest Rutherford, fired fast alpha particles (helium nuclei, charge +2) at thin metal foils. About 1 in 8,000 bounced back from platinum; later runs with gold foil about 1,400 atoms thick also gave rare bounce-backs. In 1904 J.J. Thomson had pictured the atom as a ball of spread-out positive charge with electrons in it (the “plum pudding”). Predict, then fire. Compare Thomson’s prediction with what really happened. Mission: fire at least 1,000 particles with each model, then build a claim–evidence–reasoning answer.

1. Predict: how many alpha particles will bounce back (more than 90°)?
2. Model
3. Fire alpha particles
Thomson: 0 fired · real: 0 fired (1,000 each for the mission)
Data table (counts since the last clear)
ModelFiredNearly straight (< 10°)Deflected (10°–90°)Bounced back (> 90°)Bounced back: 1 in …

Real result (Geiger and Marsden, 1909, platinum): about 1 in 8,000 bounced back by more than 90°; with thin gold foil it was about 1 in 20,000 (Rutherford, 1911). This model uses 1 in 8,000. Rutherford explained the bounce-backs in 1911 with a tiny, dense, positive nucleus; he said it was “as if you fired a 15-inch shell at a piece of tissue paper and it came back.” In the model here, each particle’s deflection comes from how close it passes to a nucleus (tan(θ/2) = b₀/b, with b₀ set so that 1 in 8,000 bounces back). The counts restart from the same sequence after a clear, so a class gets the same numbers.

📜 Mission 3 · Models Through Time Grades 7–10

Scientific models change when new evidence appears. Put the six models of the atom in the order they were proposed, using the ▲ and ▼ buttons, then match each model to the evidence that led to it. Mission: the order right and at least 5 of 6 evidence matches right on one check.

    Order: not yet · evidence matches: – / 6

    The electron-cloud model (1926) is the modern model; Chadwick’s neutron (1932) came later and completed the picture of the nucleus. Each model kept what still worked from the one before. More on energy levels and spectra: Bohr atom; on orbitals: electron configuration (Aufbau).

    🆔 Mission 4 · Atom ID Cards: Count p, n and e Grades 8–10 · HS-PS1-8

    Each card shows an atom or ion as a periodic-table box, in isotope notation (mass number top left, atomic number bottom left, charge top right) or by name. Enter the number of protons, neutrons and electrons; the drawing and readout update as you type. Mission: 6 cards right on the first check, including at least one ion and one isotope. Want to build atoms freely? Use the free Build an Atom tool on the periodic table page.

    Atomic numbers you may need: H 1 · C 6 · O 8 · F 9 · Na 11 · Al 13 · S 16 · Cl 17 · Ca 20 · Au 79 (or look them up on the periodic table).

    Cards right (first check): 0 (6 needed)
    ion: not yet · isotope: not yet

    ⚖️ Mission 5 · Isotope Lab: Mass Spectrometer Grades 8–10 · HS-PS1-8

    Most elements are a mix of isotopes: atoms with the same number of protons but different numbers of neutrons. A mass spectrometer sorts atoms by mass and counts them. Pick an element, collect a sample, then work out the average atomic mass from the real isotope masses and abundances. Mission: 2 averages right (one element with 3 isotopes) and 1 mystery spectrum right on the first pick.

    Sample size:
    Average atomic mass calculator

    For each isotope: abundance as a decimal × isotope mass. Then add the rows. Keep at least 3 decimal places.

    Averages right: 0 / 2 · with 3 isotopes: not yet
    Mystery spectra right: 0 / 1
    Isotopes
    IsotopeProtonsNeutronsMass (u)Natural abundance
    Mystery spectrum

    Masses and abundances: IUPAC / NIST isotopic compositions (u = unified atomic mass unit, 1/12 of the mass of a carbon-12 atom). Small samples give averages that wander; large samples come close to the periodic-table value. Carbon also has a trace of radioactive carbon-14 (about 1 atom in a trillion), too little to change the average.

    🟡 Mission 6 · Bohr Shells & Valence Electrons Grades 8–10 · HS-PS1-1

    In the Bohr model, electrons are found at certain energy levels (shells). The first level holds up to 2, the second up to 8 and, for the first 20 elements, the third up to 8; then the 4th level starts (potassium and calcium). Pick an element, predict its number of valence (outer-level) electrons, then place its electrons by pressing a shell (or the + buttons). Mission: 5 elements right (first prediction and arrangement), including one from period 3 (Na to Ar) and K or Ca.

    1. Predict: valence electrons?
    2. Place the electrons placed: 0
    Elements right: 0 / 5
    period 3: not yet · K or Ca: not yet

    Shells are energy levels, not tracks that electrons follow like planets around the Sun. In the modern model each electron is spread out in a cloud (an orbital) that shows where it is likely to be found; the rule 2, 8, 8, 2 is a school rule that works for elements 1 to 20. For orbitals and the full filling order, see electron configuration (Aufbau); for how valence electrons form bonds, see chemical bonding.

    🔀 Mission 7 · Isotope, Ion or New Element? Grades 8–10 · HS-PS1-8

    Each card changes one atom. Decide what you get: an isotope (neutrons change), an ion (electrons change) or a new element (protons change). Only your first choice counts. Mission: at least 8 of 10 right.

    Right: 0 / 10 · answered: 0

    In chemical reactions atoms gain, lose or share electrons, but the nucleus does not change, so they never become other elements. Changing the protons needs a nuclear reaction.

    ✅ Mission 8 · Final Quiz: Atomic Structure

    10 questions from a bank of 20. Score 7 or more to complete the mission. Each new round picks new questions in a new order.

    💡 The Idea, Step by Step

    Key facts. An atom has a tiny, dense nucleus of protons (+1) and neutrons (0), with electrons (−1) around it. The number of protons is the atomic number Z and decides the element. Protons + neutrons = the mass number A. Atoms of one element with different numbers of neutrons are isotopes; atoms that have gained or lost electrons are ions. The atomic mass on the periodic table is the average mass of an element’s isotopes. Electrons are found at energy levels (shells), and the outer ones, the valence electrons, decide how an element reacts.
    Start — atoms are tiny and mostly empty

    Everything is made of atoms, and they are small beyond imagining: about half a million carbon atoms fit across one human hair. Even stranger, an atom is almost all empty space. Its nucleus is only about 1/10,000 to 1/100,000 of its width, like a bead on the center spot of a stadium, yet it holds more than 99.9 % of the mass. We know this from evidence: in the gold foil experiment almost every alpha particle passed straight through the gold, and only about 1 in several thousand was pushed back by the tiny nucleus.

    Build — three particles
    ParticleChargeMass (u)Relative massWhere
    Proton (p)+11.007281nucleus
    Neutron (n)01.008661nucleus
    Electron (e⁻)−10.0005491/1836around the nucleus

    One charge unit is 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ coulombs. A neutral atom has as many electrons as protons, so the charges cancel. The positive nucleus and the negative electrons attract each other; that electrical attraction holds the atom together.

    Counting — Z, A and charge

    In the notation ¹⁴₆C, the bottom number is the atomic number (Z = 6 protons) and the top number is the mass number (A = 14). Neutrons = A − Z = 8. A charge in the top right counts electrons: ²³Na⁺ has 11 protons, 12 neutrons and 10 electrons, because charge = protons − electrons. Ions form when atoms gain or lose electrons; the nucleus does not change in a chemical reaction.

    Isotopes and average atomic mass

    All chlorine atoms have 17 protons, but 75.76 % have 18 neutrons (chlorine-35) and 24.24 % have 20 (chlorine-37). Isotopes of an element react the same way, because they have the same electrons. The periodic table gives the weighted average: 0.7576 × 34.969 + 0.2424 × 36.966 = 35.45 u. No single chlorine atom has a mass of 35.45 u. Most isotopes are stable; only some, such as carbon-14, are radioactive.

    Deepen — energy levels and valence electrons

    Bohr (1913) proposed that electrons can only have certain energies, the energy levels or shells. For the first 20 elements they fill as 2, 8, 8, 2: sodium is 2, 8, 1 and potassium 2, 8, 8, 1. Both have one valence electron in the outer level, which is why they react in the same way and sit in the same group. When an electron drops from a higher level to a lower one, the atom gives off light of one exact energy: that is why each element has its own flame color and line spectrum. The modern model replaces the shells with electron clouds (orbitals) that show where an electron is likely to be found.

    Try this on this page

    In Mission 2, fire 8,000 particles with each model and compare the “bounced back” column. In Mission 4, enter 8 protons with 8 and then 10 neutrons: the element stays oxygen. In Mission 5, collect 10 atoms of chlorine several times and watch the average jump around; then collect 10,000. In Mission 6, compare Na and K, or F and Cl.

    📚 Quick Reference

    Isotope notation

    A = mass number = protons + neutrons A Z X charge example: ¹⁹₉F⁻ = 9 p, 10 n, 10 e Z = atomic number = protons charge = protons − electrons

    Three formulas

    FindFormulaExample (³²S²⁻, Z = 16)
    Neutronsn = A − Z32 − 16 = 16
    Electronse = Z − charge16 − (−2) = 18
    Average atomic massΣ (abundance as a decimal × isotope mass)Cl: 0.7576 × 34.969 + 0.2424 × 36.966 = 35.45 u

    Bohr filling rule (elements 1–20)

    Energy level (shell)1234
    Holds up to (school rule, Z ≤ 20)2881–2 for K, Ca (it holds more in bigger atoms)
    ExamplesH 1, He 2C 2, 4 · Ne 2, 8Na 2, 8, 1 · Cl 2, 8, 7K 2, 8, 8, 1 · Ca 2, 8, 8, 2

    Fill from the inside out: each level is full before the next one starts. Valence electrons = electrons in the outer level = the group number for groups 1–2 and the group number minus 10 for groups 13–18 (helium: 2). Related pages: periodic table, chemical bonding, Bohr atom, electron configuration, periodic trends, states of matter.

    🎓 Going Further (High School / AP): Flame Tests, the Nucleus and Orbitals

    1. Flame-test lab: light from energy levels (HS-PS4-3 link, AP Unit 1)

    Heating a metal salt in a flame lifts electrons to higher energy levels. When an electron falls back down, the atom gives off a photon whose energy equals the gap between the levels: E = hc/λ (h = 6.626 × 10⁻³⁴ J·s, c = 2.998 × 10⁸ m/s). Each element has its own gaps, so its own colors. Pick a salt:

    For calcium, strontium and copper much of the flame color comes from small molecules formed in the flame (such as CaOH or CuCl), but the idea is the same: electrons drop between energy levels. Real-lab safety: flame tests are a teacher demonstration with goggles; strontium and copper salts are toxic. Line spectra and the Bohr energy formula are explored on the Bohr atom page.

    2. What holds the nucleus together?

    Protons repel each other strongly at nuclear distances. They stay together because of the strong nuclear force, which attracts protons and neutrons to each other but acts only over about the width of a nucleus (a few femtometers). Neutrons add this attraction without adding repulsion, which is why larger nuclei need more neutrons than protons: gold-197 has 79 protons and 118 neutrons. (Advanced: a nucleus has slightly less mass than its separate protons and neutrons; this “mass defect” corresponds to the binding energy through E = mc².)

    3. From shells to orbitals

    The Bohr model works well for hydrogen but not for atoms with many electrons. Schrödinger’s wave model (1926) describes each electron by an orbital, a 3D cloud of probability, grouped into energy levels and sublevels (s, p, d, f). The shell numbers 2, 8, 8 come from these sublevels: 2 = 1s; 8 = 2s + 2p; the third shell has room for 18, but the 4s sublevel fills before 3d, which is why potassium starts a 4th shell. See the shapes on hydrogen orbitals and the filling order on electron configuration (Aufbau).

    4. Isotopes in use

    Carbon-14 dating: living things take in a tiny, steady share of radioactive carbon-14; after death it decays with a half-life of about 5,730 years, so the share left gives the age of wood, charcoal or shells up to about 50,000 years old. Medical tracers: small amounts of short-lived isotopes, such as technetium-99m, are given to patients so that scanners can follow where they go in the body. Mass spectrometry of stable isotopes, such as oxygen-18 in ice cores, records past temperatures.

    🧑‍🏫 For Teachers: 45-Minute Lesson Plan, Worksheet & Answer Key

    Standards: NGSS MS-PS1-1 (models of atomic composition: Missions 1, 2, 4), HS-PS1-1 (patterns of outer electrons and the periodic table: Mission 6), HS-PS1-8 introduction (isotopes and nuclear change: Missions 4, 5, 7), HS-PS4-3 link (light from energy levels: flame lab). NGSS places subatomic particles mainly in high school, and the MS-PS1-1 assessment boundary excludes valence electrons; many state standards teach protons, neutrons and electrons in grade 8 (e.g., Florida SC.8.P.8.7); Bohr models are a common grade 8–9 extension. So in grade 7 use Missions 1–3 and 7 as the core; in grade 8 add Missions 4–6 (Mission 6 is enrichment beyond MS-PS1-1); in high school all 8 are core. Objective: students use evidence from the gold foil experiment to describe the nuclear atom, count protons, neutrons and electrons from notation, calculate average atomic mass from isotope data, and draw Bohr arrangements for elements 1–20.

    1. Bell-ringer (3 min). “How many atoms thick is a sheet of gold foil 0.4 µm thick?” (about 1,400). Then Mission 1 on the projector: zoom to the atom and the nucleus.
    2. Evidence for the nucleus (12 min). Mission 2 in pairs: everyone predicts first, then fires 8,000 with each model (press Clear this model’s data first so your counts match the key) and records the table on the worksheet (section B). Discuss the CER answer. Mission 3 (models through time) as a quick sort.
    3. Counting particles and isotopes (17 min). Mission 4 (Atom ID cards) and Mission 5 (isotope lab). Pairs collect 10, 100 and 10,000 atoms of chlorine and compare their averages with the class: why do small samples disagree?
    4. Shells and changes (8 min). Mission 6 for at least Na, Cl and K, then Mission 7. Ask: “Why do Na and K behave alike?”
    5. Exit ticket (5 min). Worksheet question 14. The quiz (Mission 8) and the flame-test lab work well as homework or a second lesson.

    Differentiation. Support: start with the cards that show Z (carbon-14, fluoride), use the calculator rows in Mission 5 one at a time, and give the sentence frame for the CER. Extension: E = hc/λ in the flame lab, the mass-defect note, orbitals on Aufbau. Language support: the vocabulary list below, and the particle table in “The Idea”. Misconceptions to target: electrons orbiting like planets; atoms as solid balls; the decimal mass as the mass number; isotopes as different elements or always radioactive; ions made by changing protons. Missions are saved on the student’s device; the certificate prints as proof of completion.

    Vocabulary

    Atom
    The smallest particle of an element that still has its properties: a nucleus with electrons around it.
    Nucleus
    The tiny, dense, positive center of an atom, made of protons and neutrons.
    Proton
    A particle in the nucleus with a charge of +1 and a mass of about 1 u.
    Neutron
    A particle in the nucleus with no charge and a mass of about 1 u.
    Electron
    A particle with a charge of −1 and about 1/1836 of a proton’s mass, found around the nucleus.
    Atomic number (Z)
    The number of protons in the nucleus; it decides which element the atom is.
    Mass number (A)
    The number of protons plus neutrons in a nucleus (always a whole number).
    Isotope
    One of two or more forms of an element whose atoms have the same number of protons but different numbers of neutrons.
    Ion
    An atom or group of atoms with a charge because it has gained or lost electrons.
    Atomic mass unit (u)
    1/12 of the mass of a carbon-12 atom, about 1.66 × 10⁻²⁷ kg.
    Average atomic mass
    The average mass of an element’s atoms, weighted by how common each isotope is (the decimal on the periodic table).
    Energy level (shell)
    One of the allowed energies of electrons in an atom; in the Bohr model, the shells 1, 2, 3, …
    Valence electrons
    The electrons in the outer energy level; they take part in bonding and decide how an element reacts.
    Electron cloud (orbital)
    The region where an electron is likely to be found, in the modern model of the atom.
    Alpha particle
    A helium nucleus (2 protons, 2 neutrons) given off by some radioactive atoms; used in the gold foil experiment.

    ❓ FAQ

    Key term What are the three particles in an atom?►

    Atoms are made of protons, neutrons and electrons. Protons (charge +1) and neutrons (no charge) sit in the tiny nucleus at the center and each has a mass of about 1 u. Electrons (charge −1) are found around the nucleus and have only about 1/1836 of a proton’s mass, so almost all of an atom’s mass is in its nucleus.

    Key takeaway: protons (+) and neutrons (0) in the nucleus, electrons (−) around it.
    Difference What is the difference between atomic number and mass number?►

    The atomic number (Z) is the number of protons; it decides the element, so every oxygen atom has Z = 8. The mass number (A) is the number of protons plus neutrons in one nucleus. Oxygen-16 has A = 16 and oxygen-18 has A = 18; both have Z = 8.

    Key takeaway: Z = protons; A = protons + neutrons.
    Applied How do you find the number of neutrons in an atom?►

    Subtract the atomic number from the mass number: neutrons = A − Z. Carbon-14 has A = 14 and Z = 6, so it has 8 neutrons. Gold-197 has 197 − 79 = 118 neutrons. Do not use the decimal atomic mass from the periodic table; it is an average of several isotopes.

    Key takeaway: neutrons = mass number − atomic number.
    Key term What is an isotope?►

    Isotopes are atoms of the same element (same number of protons) with different numbers of neutrons. Carbon-12, carbon-13 and carbon-14 all have 6 protons but 6, 7 and 8 neutrons. Isotopes of an element have the same electrons and react the same way. Most isotopes are stable; some, such as carbon-14, are radioactive.

    Key takeaway: same protons, different neutrons.
    Difference What is the difference between an isotope and an ion?►

    An isotope has a different number of neutrons than another atom of the same element, so its mass changes but its charge does not. An ion has gained or lost electrons, so it has a charge: Na⁺ has lost one electron and Cl⁻ has gained one. If the number of protons changes, the atom becomes a different element.

    Key takeaway: neutrons change → isotope; electrons change → ion; protons change → new element.
    Concept Why is the atomic mass on the periodic table a decimal?►

    Because it is an average of an element’s isotopes, weighted by how common each one is. Chlorine is 75.76 % chlorine-35 (34.969 u) and 24.24 % chlorine-37 (36.966 u), so the average is 35.45 u. No single chlorine atom has that mass.

    Key takeaway: it is a weighted average of the isotopes, not the mass of one atom.
    Concept What did Rutherford’s gold foil experiment show?►

    Almost all alpha particles passed straight through thin metal foil (gold foil about 1,400 atoms thick), but only about 1 in several thousand bounced back by more than 90° (about 1 in 8,000 from platinum in 1909; about 1 in 20,000 for thin gold foil). Rutherford concluded in 1911 that an atom is mostly empty space with a tiny, dense, positively charged nucleus. Thomson’s plum-pudding model, with positive charge spread through the atom, could not explain the bounce-backs.

    Key takeaway: atoms are mostly empty space around a tiny, dense, positive nucleus.
    Applied How many electrons go in each shell of a Bohr model?►

    For the first 20 elements, the school rule is 2 in the first shell, then 8, then 8, then the 4th shell starts: sodium is 2, 8, 1 and calcium is 2, 8, 8, 2. Fill from the inside out. The electrons in the outer shell are the valence electrons. (The third shell can hold 18 in heavier atoms.)

    Key takeaway: 2, 8, 8, 2 for elements 1–20, filled from the inside out.
    Concept Do electrons orbit the nucleus like planets?►

    No. Bohr’s shells are energy levels, not paths. In the modern model an electron does not follow a track at all; it is described by an orbital, a cloud that shows where the electron is likely to be found. The Bohr model is still useful for counting electrons at each energy level.

    Key takeaway: shells are energy levels; real electrons are clouds, not planets.
    Applied How small is an atom?►

    A typical atom is about 0.1 to 0.3 nanometers across (a gold atom is 0.29 nm, about 3 × 10⁻¹⁰ m). About half a million carbon atoms fit across a human hair. The nucleus is about 10,000 to 100,000 times smaller than the atom: if the atom were a 100 m stadium, the nucleus would be a bead a few millimeters wide.

    Key takeaway: about 10⁻¹⁰ m; the nucleus is 10,000–100,000 times smaller still.

    ⚠️ Misconceptions & Common Errors

    ❌ “Electrons orbit the nucleus like planets on fixed tracks.”✅ Bohr’s shells are energy levels. In the modern model an electron has no track; it is described by an orbital, a cloud of where it is likely to be found.🔍 Shells are energy levels, not paths.
    ❌ “Atoms are solid little balls.”✅ An atom is almost all empty space. The nucleus is only 1/10,000 to 1/100,000 of the atom’s width, which is why almost all alpha particles passed straight through gold foil.🔍 Atoms are mostly empty space.
    ❌ “The decimal atomic mass on the periodic table is the mass number (or the mass of one atom).”✅ It is the weighted average of the isotopes. The mass number A is always a whole number for one nucleus. Chlorine’s 35.45 comes from Cl-35 and Cl-37; no chlorine atom has a mass of 35.45 u.🔍 Atomic mass is an average; A is a count.
    ❌ “Isotopes are always radioactive, or different isotopes are different elements.”✅ Isotopes of an element have the same number of protons, so they are the same element. Most isotopes are stable (carbon-12 and carbon-13); only some, such as carbon-14, are radioactive.🔍 Same protons, same element; most isotopes are stable.
    ❌ “Ions form when atoms gain or lose protons.”✅ In chemistry only electrons are gained or lost. Changing the protons would change the element, which needs a nuclear reaction.🔍 Ions: electrons change, protons stay.
    ❌ “Neutrons are charged, and electrons weigh about the same as protons.”✅ Neutrons have no charge. An electron has only about 1/1836 of the mass of a proton, so electrons add almost nothing to an atom’s mass.🔍 Neutrons: 0 charge; electrons: 1/1836 of the mass.
    Sources for the science on this page: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, Ch. 2 (atomic structure, isotopes, average atomic mass) and Ch. 6 (the Bohr model, electronic structure); NIST Atomic Weights and Isotopic Compositions and IUPAC standard atomic weights (isotope masses and abundances); NIST CODATA (particle masses and the elementary charge); H. Geiger & E. Marsden (1909), Proc. R. Soc. A 82, 495 (about 1 in 8,000 alpha particles reflected from platinum); E. Rutherford (1911), Phil. Mag. 21, 669 (about 1 in 20,000 for thin gold foil); J. Chadwick (1932), Nature 129, 312; Royal Society of Chemistry, Education in Chemistry (teaching atomic structure at 14–16) and K. S. Taber (2002), Chemical Misconceptions (students’ models of the atom); NGSS MS-PS1-1, HS-PS1-1, HS-PS1-8.