← SciSim / Biology

Griffith’s Experiment (1928): Bacterial Transformation

🧫 Tier: High School → College Biology (AP Biology, IB, A-level, undergraduate genetics) · English & العربية
In 1928 Frederick Griffith injected mice with two strains of Streptococcus pneumoniae: the deadly, capsule-coated S strain and the harmless R strain. Dead S cells were harmless and live R cells were harmless, yet the mixture killed the mouse and live S-type bacteria grew from its blood. Run all four experiments in 3D, look down the microscope, follow the DNA into an R cell, and repeat Avery’s 1944 enzyme test. The simulation can be switched to Arabic (العربية).

🧫 3D Griffith Lab: Four Mice and a Surprise

Live bacteria per mL of blood (illustrative model)

Conclusion

S and R pneumococci

Click a mouse, a tube, the water bath, a plate or the microscope, or a key word in the panel.

Language

Experiment

View

Key words

For teachers

💡This simulation was requested by a teacher in Algeria through SciSim’s request form, which is why it also runs in Arabic. Is there a topic you wish you could see? Request a simulation →

🧪 Avery, MacLeod & McCarty (1944): Which Molecule Transforms?

🏷️ Labeled Diagram: S and R Pneumococci & Label Quiz

The diagram you meet in a test: an S cell with its capsule, an R cell without one, the DNA that transforms R into S, and the two kinds of colony. Switch between the labeled diagram, a blank one to test your memory, and a quiz where you place each label yourself. You can also download both versions.

S strain (smooth)R strain (rough)released by a heat-killed S cellS colonies: smooth, shinyR colonies: rough, dullGriffith’s Experiment · scisim.org

    Tap a word, then tap the numbered box it belongs to (on the diagram or in the list below). Tap a filled box to take the word back. On a phone, swipe the diagram sideways to see every number.

    Download:

    🎮 Practice: Quiz & Sorting Games

    Griffith’s experiment quiz

    Ten questions, chosen at random from twenty, about the experiment, the two strains and what it proved.

    Does the mouse live or die?

    Tap an injection, then tap what happens to the mouse. Some of these Griffith never tried: use what you know about the capsule and transformation.

    ❌ The mouse dies

    ✅ The mouse survives

    S strain or R strain?

    Sort the ten features.

    S strain (smooth)

    R strain (rough)

    💡 The Idea, Step by Step

    Key idea: something that survives heat in dead S bacteria can enter living R bacteria and permanently change what they inherit. it was later called the transforming principle; in 1944 Avery, MacLeod and McCarty showed that it is DNA. This was the first strong evidence that genes are made of DNA.
    Start — two strains of the same bacterium

    Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) causes pneumonia. Under the microscope its cells come in pairs (diplococci). The S strain wraps each pair in a slimy polysaccharide capsule, so its colonies look smooth and shiny. The R strain is a mutant that cannot make the capsule; its colonies look rough. (The R strain in these experiments was derived from a type II S strain.) The capsule is what makes S dangerous: white blood cells called phagocytes cannot easily grip it, so S cells escape and multiply in the blood. R cells are engulfed and cleared.

    Build — three controls and a surprise

    Live S kills a mouse. Live R does not. S cells killed by heat do not, because dead cells cannot multiply. Those three results are the controls: each shows what one ingredient does on its own. Then Griffith injected live R together with heat-killed S. Neither should kill, yet many mice died, and live, encapsulated S-type bacteria grew from their blood. Heat-killed S alone never produced living bacteria, so the living cells must have come from the R strain: the R cells had been transformed.

    Deepen — what is transferred, and why it is inherited

    Heating kills the cells but leaves much of their DNA intact. Pieces of chromosome from the dead S cells, carrying the working capsule genes, are taken up by a few R cells. One strand enters and lines up with the matching stretch of the R chromosome, swapping the R cell’s faulty capsule genes for the S strain’s set (homologous recombination). The cell can now make capsule, and because the change is in its chromosome, every daughter cell inherits it. The capsule type of the recovered cells matched the dead strain, not the R strain’s original parent, so this was not just a reverse mutation. Griffith did not know what the transferred material was; Avery’s group purified it and showed that only enzymes that destroy DNA stopped it.

    Try this on the page

    (1) New to the topic? Open the 2D diagram view first: all four experiments side by side on one screen. (2) Turn on Predict first and run experiments 1 to 4; check your score. (3) Run experiment 4 in the Microscope view and watch phagocytes engulf the R cells while a few orange transformed cells multiply. (4) Open the Molecular view and step through how the DNA gets in. (5) In Design your own, try live R + heat-killed R: why does that mouse live? (6) Do Avery’s enzyme test and predict every plate before you incubate.

    📋 Results & Evidence

    Griffith’s results (1928)

    ExperimentInjectedMouseLive bacteria recovered from the bloodWhat it shows
    1Live SDiesLive SThe S strain is virulent (control)
    2Live RSurvivesNoneThe R strain is not virulent (control)
    3Heat-killed SSurvivesNoneDead S cells cannot cause disease (control)
    4Live R + heat-killed SDiesLive, encapsulated S-typeLiving R cells were transformed by material from the dead S cells

    In Griffith’s own work the bacteria were injected under the skin of mice; not every mouse given the mixture died, and transformation was a rare event in each mouse. The simulation shows a typical outcome. Its “bacteria in the blood” graph is an illustrative model (growth, clearance by phagocytes and a small transformation rate) chosen to reproduce the classic results, not measured data.

    Avery, MacLeod & McCarty (1944)

    Treatment of the purified extract from type III S cellsTransformation of R cells?Conclusion
    NoneYesThe extract contains the transforming principle
    Protein-digesting enzymes (trypsin, chymotrypsin)YesIt is not a protein
    Ribonuclease (destroys RNA)YesIt is not RNA
    Enzymes that break down DNANoIt is DNA

    The purified material also had the nitrogen-to-phosphorus ratio expected for DNA (about 1.67), and as little as about 0.003 µg was enough to transform R cells. Transformed cells were seen as large, glistening, smooth colonies among the small, rough R colonies, and their new capsule type was passed on to every later generation.

    From transformation to the double helix

    YearWhoFinding
    1928Frederick GriffithBacterial transformation: a “transforming principle” from dead S cells changes living R cells
    1944Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod, Maclyn McCartyThe transforming principle is DNA
    1952Alfred Hershey & Martha ChaseWhen a bacteriophage infects a bacterium, its DNA (not its protein coat) enters the cell
    1953James Watson & Francis Crick (using data from Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins)The double-helix structure of DNA, which explains how genes are copied
    References: Griffith F (1928), “The significance of pneumococcal types”, Journal of Hygiene 27(2):113–159; Avery OT, MacLeod CM & McCarty M (1944), “Studies on the chemical nature of the substance inducing transformation of pneumococcal types”, Journal of Experimental Medicine 79(2):137–158; Hershey AD & Chase M (1952), Journal of General Physiology 36(1):39–56; Urry LA et al., Campbell Biology (chapter “The Molecular Basis of Inheritance”).

    ❓ FAQ

    Conceptual What was Griffith’s experiment?►

    In 1928 Frederick Griffith injected mice with two strains of Streptococcus pneumoniae. Live S (capsulated) bacteria killed the mice; live R (no capsule) bacteria and heat-killed S bacteria did not. But a mixture of live R and heat-killed S killed the mice, and live S-type bacteria were recovered from their blood. Something from the dead S cells had transformed the living R cells.

    Key takeaway: a mixture of two harmless injections killed the mouse because R bacteria were transformed into S-type.
    Basics What is the difference between the S and R strains?►

    The S (smooth) strain makes a polysaccharide capsule, forms smooth shiny colonies and is virulent. The R (rough) strain is a mutant that cannot make the capsule, forms rough colonies and is not virulent, because phagocytes can engulf it.

    Key takeaway: S = capsule, smooth, deadly; R = no capsule, rough, harmless.
    Mechanism Why does the capsule make the S strain deadly?►

    The slippery polysaccharide capsule makes it hard for phagocytes (white blood cells such as neutrophils and macrophages) to grip and engulf the bacteria. The S cells therefore survive, multiply in the blood and cause septicaemia. Without the capsule, the immune system clears R cells quickly.

    Key takeaway: the capsule protects S bacteria from being eaten by phagocytes.
    Evidence Why did the mouse die when given live R and heat-killed S?►

    Some of the living R cells took up DNA released from the dead S cells, including working capsule genes. They began to make capsules, escaped the phagocytes, multiplied and killed the mouse. Their offspring were also encapsulated, so live S-type bacteria were found in the blood.

    Key takeaway: living R cells were transformed into virulent S-type cells.
    Misconception Did the heat-killed S bacteria come back to life?►

    No. Heat-killed S bacteria injected on their own never produced living bacteria or disease. The living bacteria in experiment 4 came from the R strain: they had gained the capsule of the dead strain’s type. The dead cells supplied only genetic material.

    Key takeaway: dead S cells do not revive; living R cells are changed.
    History Did Griffith prove that DNA is the genetic material?►

    No. Griffith showed that transformation happens, but he did not identify the substance responsible (later called the transforming principle). In 1944 Avery, MacLeod and McCarty purified it and showed that only enzymes that destroy DNA stopped transformation, so it is DNA. Hershey and Chase (1952) added further evidence with viruses.

    Key takeaway: Griffith discovered transformation; Avery and colleagues showed it is caused by DNA.
    Experiment design Why were experiments 1, 2 and 3 needed?►

    They are controls. They show that live S kills, live R does not and heat-killed S does not. Without them, a death in experiment 4 could have been blamed on either ingredient alone. With them, the only explanation left is that the ingredients interacted.

    Key takeaway: controls show what each ingredient does alone.
    Deep How do bacteria take up DNA during transformation?►

    Some bacteria, including pneumococci, can become naturally competent: they make surface proteins that bind DNA fragments from the surroundings. One strand is pulled into the cell while the other is broken down. If the strand matches part of the chromosome, it can replace that stretch by homologous recombination, so a faulty gene can be swapped for a working one.

    Key takeaway: competent cells take in one strand of DNA and recombine it into their chromosome.
    Applied Why does Griffith’s experiment still matter today?►

    Transformation is one of the ways bacteria share genes, including genes for antibiotic resistance and new capsule types that let pneumococci escape vaccines. It is also a basic laboratory tool: scientists transform bacteria with DNA to make insulin and other medicines and to study genes.

    Key takeaway: transformation spreads genes in nature and is used in genetic engineering.
    Basics What is the transforming principle?►

    It is the name later given to the unknown substance from heat-killed S bacteria that changed living R bacteria into S-type in Griffith’s experiment. It survives heat, it changes inherited characteristics, and it was later identified as DNA.

    Key takeaway: the transforming principle is DNA.

    ⚠️ Misconceptions & Common Errors

    ❌ "The dead S bacteria came back to life in the mouse."✅ Heat-killed S alone never produced living bacteria. Living R cells took up DNA from the dead cells and were transformed.🔍 Transformation changes living cells; it does not revive dead ones.
    ❌ "Griffith proved that DNA is the genetic material."✅ Griffith showed that transformation happens. Avery, MacLeod and McCarty identified the transforming principle as DNA in 1944.🔍 Keep the two discoveries, and their dates, apart.
    ❌ "The R strain is a different species from the S strain."✅ Both are Streptococcus pneumoniae. R strains are mutants that lost the ability to make the capsule.🔍 Same species, different genes for the capsule.
    ❌ "The capsule is a toxin that poisons the mouse."✅ The capsule is a protective coat. It lets S bacteria avoid phagocytes and multiply; the disease comes from the uncontrolled infection.🔍 The capsule protects; it is not a poison.
    ❌ "The R cells took the capsule itself from the dead cells, like borrowing a coat."✅ They took up genes and made their own capsule. Their offspring also had capsules, so the change was inherited.🔍 Transformation is a change in genes, so it is heritable.
    ❌ "Heating destroys everything inside a bacterium."✅ Heat kills the cell and destroys many proteins, but DNA is more heat-stable and can still transform other cells.🔍 A dead cell can still contain working DNA.
    Education research: students often think genetic information moves only from parents to offspring and struggle to connect DNA, genes and traits (Lewis & Wood-Robinson, 2000, “Genes, chromosomes, cell division and inheritance – do students see any relationship?”, International Journal of Science Education 22(2):177–195). Seeing a trait move between living cells, and the controls that rule out other explanations, makes the link between DNA and inheritance concrete.