🌎
Community request
Requested by u/tenderhart on Reddit — “I'd love some environmental ones like the carbon cycle…”

Carbon Cycle Interactive: Diagram, BTB Jar Lab, Keeling Curve & 3D Model

🌍 Grades 6–10 (MS-LS2-3, MS-LS1-6/7, MS-ESS3-5) · HS / AP (HS-LS2-5, HS-ESS2-6, HS-ESS3-6)

Follow carbon through the air, plants, animals, soil, ocean and rocks. Watch the 8 processes, label the diagram, test a snail and an Elodea water plant in a virtual BTB jar lab, graph real CO₂ data from Mauna Loa and balance Earth’s carbon budget. High school and AP students can then run the 3D Earth box model.

Jump to: Processes · Label lab · Carbon stores · BTB jar lab · Keeling Curve · Carbon budget · Sort · Quiz · 3D model (AP) · Quick reference · Going further · For teachers · Misconceptions · FAQ

🎯 8 Missions 0 / 8For teachers

A 45-minute class: do the missions in order. Your progress is saved on this device.

1 · Carbon Cycle Diagram: Processes & Carbon Atom Game Mission 1

This diagram shows the carbon cycle the way you learn it in school (middle and high school); the AP 3D model of the whole planet is further down, in section 9. Choose a process to watch carbon atoms move along its arrow, or play Follow a carbon atom: roll the dice, see where your atom goes, and name each process.

Choose a process

Tap a button or an arrow on the diagram. Carbon atoms (black dots) will move along the arrow, and this box explains what happens.

🎯 Mission 1: Watch the processesseen 0 / 8 · answered 0 / 3 · first try 0

Press all 8 process buttons above (or Play all processes). Then predict: does each process add CO₂ to the air, remove it, or only move carbon between other stores? Press Watch it to check on the diagram.

The Follow a carbon atom dice game is an extra: try it after the missions.

Adds CO₂ to the air respiration, decomposition, combustion, ocean release
Removes CO₂ from the air photosynthesis, dissolving in the ocean
Moves carbon between stores feeding, death & waste, fossilization
For teachers:

2 · Labeled Carbon Cycle Diagram & Label Quiz Mission 2

This is the carbon cycle diagram you draw and label in a test. Switch between the labeled diagram, a blank one to test your memory, and a quiz where you place each label yourself. You can also download both versions or print a label worksheet.

The carbon cycle (simplified, not to scale) · scisim.org

    Tap a word, then tap the numbered box it belongs to (on the diagram or in the list below). Tap a filled box to take the word back. On a phone, swipe the diagram sideways to see every number.

    Download:
    🎯 Mission 2: Label quizfirst check: not yet

    Open the Label quiz, place all 13 labels, then press Check answers. All right, or at least 80 % (11 of 13) on the first check, completes the mission. Try again starts a new round.

    3 · Where Is the Carbon? Earth’s Carbon Stores Mission 3

    Here are seven of Earth’s big carbon stores. Put them in order from the smallest store to the largest with the ▲ and ▼ buttons, then press Check my order. The bar chart then shows the real sizes, in gigatonnes of carbon (1 GtC = 1 billion metric tons).

    Smallest at the top ↓ largest at the bottom

      Log scale: each step on the axis is 10 times more carbon. “× the air” = how many times the carbon in the air (900 GtC).

      Predict, then check with the chartfirst try 0 / 2

      Numbers: IPCC AR6 (2021), Figure 5.12, rounded. Soils do not include the ~1,400 GtC in permafrost.

      4 · BTB Jar Lab: Snails, Elodea, Light & Dark Mission 4

      Bromothymol blue (BTB) is a color indicator: blue in fresh water, green with some dissolved CO₂, yellow with a lot (CO₂ makes water slightly acidic). Four sealed tubes hold BTB water: A water only, B a snail, C an Elodea water plant, D a snail and an Elodea. Choose light or dark and the starting color, predict, then run 24 hours.

      0 h
      1 · Light
      2 · Starting color
      3 · Predict
      After 24 hours, which tubes will be more yellow (more CO₂) than at the start?
      Data table: pH and color every 4 hours (this setup)
      TimeA waterB snailC ElodeaD snail + Elodea

      Mission: at least 3 runs with predictions (light and dark), then 4 questions with at least 3 right on the first try.

      📝 CER: Do plants respire? (extra)

      Virtual snails: no animals harmed. The numbers are illustrative, but they follow real class results (snail tubes turn yellow overnight; Elodea in bright light turns breathed-in BTB green and then blue again within a day).

      5 · Keeling Curve Lab: Real CO₂ Data from Mauna Loa Mission 5

      Since 1958, scientists have measured CO₂ in the air on the Mauna Loa volcano in Hawaii, far from cities and forests. The graph shows NOAA’s yearly averages, 1959–2023 in ppm (parts per million: 421 ppm = 421 CO₂ molecules in every million molecules of air). Move the year slider to read the graph.

      1990

      Fact: the May 2024 monthly average was 426.90 ppm (◆ on the graph), and the record keeps rising: in May 2025 it reached about 430.5 ppm (NOAA).

      4 tasksdone 0 / 4 · first try 0
      a) Read the graph. CO₂ in 1960 and in 2020?
      ppmppm
      b) How fast is it rising? Rise per year in the 1960s (1960 → 1970) and in the 2010s (2010 → 2020). (ppm at the end − ppm at the start) ÷ 10 years
      ppm/yrppm/yr
      c) Turn on the yearly zigzag.
      d) Predict 2030 by extending the trend of the last 10 years.
      ppm

      Data: NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory, Mauna Loa CO₂ annual mean (co2_annmean_mlo), public domain.

      6 · Carbon Budget Lab: the CO₂ Bathtub Mission 6

      Think of the air as a bathtub. Emissions are the tap; the ocean and land plants are the drain. The drain gets faster when there is more CO₂ in the air, but slower as the ocean and land fill up. Uptake = the carbon the ocean and plants take out of the air each year. Net emissions = what we add (fossil fuels + cutting forests) minus what newly planted trees take back. Start in 2023 at 421.08 ppm, set the sliders (GtC per year), and run the model to 2100.

      Simple teaching model: uptake = 0.0734 × (CO₂ − “full” level) GtC per year, split ocean 58 % / land 42 %. The “full” level is 339 ppm in 2023 and rises as the ocean and land take up carbon (by 30 % of the carbon they take up, counted in ppm); 2.124 GtC = 1 ppm. Real sinks also change as the climate warms.

      10.3
      1.3
      0.0
      Scenarios (start from today’s 11.6 GtC/yr)
      Table every 10 years
      YearEmissions (GtC/yr)Uptake (GtC/yr)CO₂ (ppm)
      3 challengesdone 0 / 3 · first try 0
      1) Keep CO₂ flat this year. Move the sliders until “CO₂ changes by” is about 0, then check. What are the net emissions?
      2) Run the three scenarios. Which ones keep CO₂ under 450 ppm in 2100? Tick all that do.
      3) Predict, then check.

      7 · Sort It: Adds, Removes or Moves? Mission 7

      Press a card, then choose where it belongs. Adds CO₂ to the air, removes CO₂ from the air, or only moves carbon between other stores (the air does not change)? Your first choice counts: 11 of 14 completes the mission.

      Cardsright 0 · placed 0 / 14

      8 · Carbon Cycle Quiz Mission 8

      10 questions from a bank of 20. Score 7 or more to complete the mission. Each answer comes with an explanation.

      9 · AP / HS: 3D Earth Carbon Model

      For high school and AP Environmental Science: a simplified box model of the whole planet (atmosphere, vegetation, soil, ocean and fossil reserves, starting near 410 ppm) in which you change human emissions and rate constants, run scenarios and the story walkthrough, and export a CSV.

      👁 See It Clearly
      🌍 3D Earth
      🔀 Reservoir Flow
      📈 CO₂ vs Time
      Pre-industrial baseline
      Atmosphere ≈ 280 ppm CO₂. Photosynthesis and respiration are roughly balanced. Move the sliders to disturb the equilibrium.
      Year 0
      Atmospheric CO₂
      426 ppm
      Ocean C (PgC)
      38,000
      Vegetation (PgC)
      550
      Soil (PgC)
      1,500
      Fossil carbon left (PgC)
      4,000
      Long-term ΔT for this CO₂ (°C, toy)
      +1.1
      Year
      2025

      Observed warming so far is about 1.3 °C; the ocean delays the rest. ΔT here is the long-term warming for the CO₂ level (3 °C per doubling, toy model).

      ▶ Playback
      📖 Story Walkthrough
      Auto-advance
      ⚙ Scenario
      🎚 Anthropogenic Forcings
      🌿 Biospheric Parameters
      ⏱ Simulation
      🎛 Display
      Flow particles
      Reservoir labels
      Auto-rotate Earth
      Clouds

      10 · Quick Reference

      Carbon stores (GtC, rounded)

      StoreCarbon× the air
      Living plants~4500.5
      Atmosphere (2023)~9001
      Surface ocean~9001
      Fossil fuel reserves~9301
      Soils (+ ~1,400 permafrost)~1,7001.9
      Deep ocean~37,00041
      Sedimentary rocks> 60,000,000> 66,000

      4 key numbers

      • ≈ 425 ppm CO₂ in 2025, up from 280 ppm before 1750 (about 52 % more).
      • ~11.6 GtC per year from humans: fossil fuels ~10.3 + land use (deforestation) ~1.3 (2024).
      • About half stays in the air; the ocean takes ~29 %, land plants ~21 % (last 10 years).
      • 1 ppm ≈ 2.12 GtC of carbon in the atmosphere.

      The 8 processes

      ProcessEffect on the airWord equation or path
      PhotosynthesisRemoves CO₂carbon dioxide + water → glucose + oxygen (light energy)
      RespirationAdds CO₂glucose + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water (+ energy)
      FeedingMoves carbonplant → animal → animal (food chains)
      Death & wasteMoves carbonliving things → dead matter and waste in the soil
      DecompositionAdds CO₂decomposers respire: glucose + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water
      FossilizationMoves carbonburied remains → coal, oil, gas; shells → limestone (millions of years)
      CombustionAdds CO₂fuel + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water (+ energy)
      Ocean exchangeBoth waysCO₂ dissolves into cold water (removes); warm water releases it (adds)

      Fast and slow carbon cycle

      Fast cycle (days to centuries): photosynthesis, respiration, feeding, decomposition and ocean–air exchange move about 200 GtC every year each way between air, living things, soil and ocean, almost in balance. Slow cycle (millions of years): fossilization, rock formation, weathering and volcanoes move only a fraction of a GtC per year. Burning fossil fuels takes carbon from the slow cycle and puts it into the fast cycle in decades, so CO₂ in the air rises.

      11 · Going Further (HS / AP)

      Ocean acidification calculator

      pH is a log scale: [H⁺] = 10−pH. When CO₂ dissolves it forms carbonic acid (CO₂ + H₂O ⇌ H₂CO₃ ⇌ H⁺ + HCO₃⁻), and the extra H⁺ also turns carbonate (CO₃²⁻) into bicarbonate, leaving less carbonate for shells (CaCO₃).

      Residence time vs adjustment time

      Every year about 200 GtC moves from the air into plants (~120) and the ocean (~80), and almost as much comes back. So an individual CO₂ molecule stays in the air only about 900 ÷ 200 ≈ 4–5 years (its residence time). But an excess of CO₂ is removed only as fast as the net uptake, a few GtC per year: much of it takes decades to centuries, and about a fifth is still in the air after 1,000 years (the adjustment time). Swapping molecules is fast; draining the extra carbon is slow.

      The Suess effect: a fingerprint of fossil carbon

      Plants prefer the lighter isotope carbon-12, so plant-made carbon (and the coal, oil and gas made from ancient plants) is low in carbon-13 and, being millions of years old, has no carbon-14 left. As fossil CO₂ is added, the share of ¹³C in the air (δ¹³C) falls and ¹⁴C is diluted. Both trends are measured, and they show that the extra CO₂ comes from fossil fuels, not from volcanoes or the ocean.

      Build a quantitative model (HS-ESS2-6)

      The Carbon Budget Lab uses two equations: dC/dt = (E − k(C − Cb)) ÷ 2.124 and Cb = 280 + 0.3 × S ÷ 2.124, where S is the carbon the ocean and land have taken up since 1850 (about 420 GtC by 2023). Check it by hand: in 2023, Cb = 280 + 0.3 × 420 ÷ 2.124 = 339.3 ppm and k(C − Cb) = 0.0734 × (421.08 − 339.3) = 6.0 GtC/yr, so with E = 11.6 the rise is 5.6 ÷ 2.124 = 2.6 ppm/yr and the airborne fraction is 5.6 ÷ 11.6 ≈ 48 %. The rising Cb is a simple stand-in for the surface ocean filling up; it is why CO₂ falls only slowly after emissions stop. Then use the 3D Earth model, which tracks vegetation, soil and ocean separately with rate constants kP, kR and kO, to see which assumption changes the 2100 result most.

      12 · The Whole Thing in One Sentence

      🛁 The bathtub analogy

      Think of the atmosphere as a bathtub. The tap is everything that adds CO₂ — factories, cars, deforestation. The drain is everything that removes CO₂ — forests photosynthesizing, oceans dissolving it. For 10,000 years the tap and drain were balanced, so the water level stayed around 280 ppm. Since 1850 we've opened the tap much wider than the drain can handle, and the level keeps rising. The higher the level, the warmer the climate gets. That's the whole story.

      What each slider in the 3D model does, in plain words

      SliderReal-world meaning
      Fossil-fuel burningHow much coal/oil/gas humanity is burning per year. Bigger = tap wide open.
      DeforestationCutting forests releases stored carbon. Negative values = planting forests (drain bigger).
      Cement / industryMaking cement chemically releases CO₂ even before fuel is burned.
      Photosynthesis kPHow efficiently plants soak up CO₂. Healthier biosphere = bigger drain.
      Respiration kRHow fast plants/soil release CO₂ back. Warmer Earth = bigger leak back into the tub.
      Ocean uptake kOHow quickly the ocean dissolves atmospheric CO₂. Slow but steady drain.

      13 · The Idea, Step by Step

      Picture carbon as money that never gets created or destroyed — it only moves between accounts. There are four accounts: the air (a small checking account you spend from every day), living things and soil (a medium savings account), the ocean (a huge, slow vault), and fossil fuels underground (an old safe nobody touched for millions of years). For thousands of years the same amount flowed into the air account as flowed out, so its balance held steady near 280 ppm. Then humanity cracked open the old safe and started shoveling its carbon into the air faster than the savings and vault accounts can take it back.

      To put numbers on it, think of one simple rule: change equals what comes in minus what goes out. Over a year the air's carbon $A$ changes by

      $$\Delta A \;=\; (\text{sources} - \text{sinks}) \times \Delta t.$$

      Right now humans add about $11.6$ PgC (= GtC) each year (fossil fuels $\approx 10.3$ + land use $\approx 1.3$), while forests and oceans together pull back roughly $6$ PgC. So about $5.6$ PgC stays in the air per year. Multiply by the conversion $0.471$ ppm per PgC and you get $\approx 2.6$ ppm/yr, close to the 2.4–2.6 ppm/yr measured at Mauna Loa in recent years. That single subtraction is the whole crisis in one line.

      The deeper, AP-level picture replaces those two lumps with one balance equation for every account. For the atmosphere,

      $$\frac{dA}{dt} = \underbrace{E_{ff} + E_{lu}}_{\text{human sources}} \;-\; \underbrace{P}_{\text{photosynthesis}} \;+\; \underbrace{R_V + R_S}_{\text{respiration}} \;-\; \underbrace{k_O\,(A - A_{eq})}_{\text{ocean uptake}}.$$

      Each slider in the panel above is one term here: Fossil-fuel burning sets $E_{ff}$, Deforestation sets $E_{lu}$ (negative values plant forests instead), Photosynthesis $k_P$ scales $P$, Respiration $k_R$ scales the leak-back $R_V$, and Ocean uptake $k_O$ controls how fast the vault drains the air toward its equilibrium $A_{eq}\approx 280$ ppm. Notice the ocean term only pulls while $A > A_{eq}$, and it pulls slowly — which is why the air stays high for centuries even after the sources stop.

      New to the topic? Start with the processes, the BTB jar lab and the carbon budget lab.

      Try this in the 3D model above. First press Run as-is and watch CO₂ and ΔT climb together. Then drag Fossil-fuel burning, Deforestation and Cement to $0$: CO₂ stops rising and then falls only slowly, because the sinks take up just a few PgC per year. Stopping emissions stops the rise; it does not quickly undo it. Finally set Deforestation negative (reforestation) and raise Ocean uptake $k_O$, and watch how much harder the sinks have to work just to bend the line back down.

      14 · The Physics & Chemistry (the equations behind the 3D model)

      Carbon is conserved. It does not disappear; it merely moves between four major reservoirs: the atmosphere (as CO₂ & CH₄), the terrestrial biosphere (plants & soils), the oceans (dissolved inorganic carbon), and lithospheric reserves (fossil fuels, carbonate rock). Burning fossil fuels and deforesting land take carbon out of slow reservoirs and dump it into the fastest one — the atmosphere — where it warms the climate until the slower reservoirs catch up.

      14.1 · State variables & conservation

      Let A, V, S, O, F be carbon (in PgC = petagrams = 10¹⁵ g) in atmosphere, vegetation, soil, ocean, and fossil reserves. Mass conservation:

      $$\frac{dA}{dt} = -P + R_V + R_S - \Phi_{O\leftrightarrow A} + E_{ff} + E_{lu}$$ $$\frac{dV}{dt} = P - R_V - L - D$$ $$\frac{dS}{dt} = L - R_S$$ $$\frac{dO}{dt} = \Phi_{O\leftrightarrow A}$$ $$\frac{dF}{dt} = -E_{ff}$$
      SymbolMeaningTypical value
      PPhotosynthesis (gross primary productivity)kP·Aeq·(1 + 0.4 ln(A/Aeq))·tanh(V/600) ≈ 95 PgC/yr in the model (real gross photosynthesis ≈ 120)
      RVAutotrophic (plant) respirationkR·V ≈ 44 PgC/yr
      RSHeterotrophic (soil) respirationkS·S ≈ 48 PgC/yr
      LLitterfall (V → S)kL·V ≈ 50 PgC/yr
      ΦO↔ANet ocean → atmosphere fluxkO·(A − Aeq)
      EffFossil-fuel + cement emissions10 PgC/yr (2025)
      EluLand-use change (deforestation)~1 PgC/yr

      The ocean–atmosphere exchange is approximated as a relaxation toward chemical equilibrium with partial pressure of CO₂:

      $$\Phi_{O\leftrightarrow A} = -k_O \left(A - A_{eq}\right), \qquad A_{eq} \approx 280\ \text{ppm-equivalent}$$

      14.2 · From PgC to parts-per-million

      One petagram of atmospheric carbon corresponds to about 0.471 ppm (1 PgC = 10¹⁵ g ÷ 12 g/mol ≈ 8.3 × 10¹³ mol of carbon, so of CO₂; dry air ≈ 5.15 × 10¹⁸ kg ÷ 29 g/mol ≈ 1.78 × 10²⁰ mol; ratio ≈ 0.47 ppm). So when emissions push A up by 11.6 PgC, ppm rises by ~5.5, and because the ocean & biosphere together take up about half, we measure ~2.5 ppm/yr at Mauna Loa.

      14.3 · Climate sensitivity (toy)

      To turn CO₂ change into a temperature, the simulation uses the logarithmic forcing law and a 3 °C-per-doubling sensitivity:

      $$\Delta T = \lambda \cdot \frac{\ln(C/C_0)}{\ln 2}, \qquad \lambda = 3\ \text{K}, \qquad C_0 = 280\ \text{ppm}$$

      15 · How the 3D Model Works, Step by Step

      1. Initialize reservoirs. The default scenario starts at 2025: A = 905 PgC (~426 ppm), V = 550, S = 1500, O = 38 000, F = 4000 (fossil reserves + resources that are harder to extract).
      2. Each tick (Δt = 0.05 yr by default) we compute flows. Photosynthesis P = kP·Aeq·(1 + 0.4 ln(A/Aeq))·tanh(V/600) grows with atmospheric CO₂ (the CO₂ fertilization effect), but only with its logarithm, and it saturates as vegetation fills up.
      3. Respiration + soil decomposition return carbon to the atmosphere. Warmer soils respire faster (Q₁₀ ≈ 2), but the simulator keeps the rate constants user-controllable for clarity.
      4. Ocean exchange is slow. The ocean uptake constant kO ≈ 0.011/yr (about 3.4 PgC/yr today) means a CO₂ pulse takes many decades to relax — explaining the long tail of climate damage.
      5. Fossil emissions and land-use change add carbon. Both come straight out of geological storage; the planet has no way to put them back on human timescales.
      6. The 3D Earth visualizes the budget: dim orange particles = fossil flux, green = photosynthesis, brown = respiration, blue = ocean exchange. Particle count is proportional to the flow rate.
      7. The flow tab shows the box-and-arrow diagram. The chart tab plots CO₂ ppm against year.

      16 · Worked Example (3D model)

      If we burned 4,000 PgC of fossil carbon (known reserves ≈ 930 plus resources that are harder to extract)

      Set fossil emissions to 30 PgC/yr (extreme growth) and press Run. In about a century (by 2125) the atmosphere climbs from ~905 to ~1,950 PgC, roughly 920 ppm: high enough for a long-term ΔT ≈ +5.1 °C above pre-industrial in this toy model. In the real Earth system, about 20–35 % of such a pulse would still be in the air after 2,000 years (Archer et al. 2009); this simple model cannot show that long tail. Try it: set the sliders, press Run, and watch.

      17 · For Teachers

      Everything runs in the browser on classroom laptops, tablets and phones: no login, no data collected. Mission progress stays on each student’s device; the certificate prints with the student’s name.

      45-minute lesson plan

      All 8 missions in one lesson is tight; for younger classes use two periods (Missions 1–4, then 5–8).

      TimeActivity
      0–5 minHook: “Where does the carbon in a tree come from?” Quick vote (air, soil, water). Optional live demo: a student blows through a straw into BTB.
      5–12 minMissions 1–2: watch the 8 processes and predict adds / removes / moves; label quiz.
      12–17 minMission 3: order the carbon stores; discuss the log scale (each step is 10 times more).
      17–27 minMission 4: BTB jar lab in pairs (one light run, one dark run, one breathed-in run); fill the data table on the worksheet.
      27–35 minMission 5: Keeling Curve tasks (read, rate of rise, zigzag, prediction).
      35–41 minMission 6: carbon budget challenges; class discussion of the scenarios.
      41–45 minMissions 7–8: sort and quiz (or for homework). Exit ticket on the worksheet.

      Worksheet and answer key

      One printable page per student (stores, BTB data table, Keeling tasks, budget challenges, sort, exit ticket) and a key with every value from the page’s models.

      The older diagram worksheet (label the diagram, match processes, dice game) is still in section 1: Print worksheet + answer key.

      Vocabulary (16 terms)

      Carbon cycle
      the movement of carbon between the air, living things, soil, ocean and rocks
      Carbon store (reservoir)
      a place where carbon is kept, such as the atmosphere or the deep ocean
      Carbon sink
      a store that takes in more carbon than it releases (forests, the ocean today)
      Carbon source
      something that releases more carbon than it takes in (burning fuel, a fire)
      Photosynthesis
      plants and algae use light energy to make glucose from carbon dioxide and water
      Cellular respiration
      cells break down glucose with oxygen to release energy, giving off carbon dioxide
      Producer / consumer
      producers make their own food by photosynthesis; consumers get carbon by eating
      Decomposer
      a bacterium or fungus that feeds on dead matter and releases CO₂
      Combustion
      burning: a fuel reacts with oxygen and releases carbon dioxide and energy
      Fossil fuel
      coal, oil or natural gas formed from buried remains over millions of years
      Fossilization
      the slow change of buried remains into fossil fuels or rock
      ppm
      parts per million: 421 ppm CO₂ = 421 CO₂ molecules per million molecules of air
      Keeling Curve
      the graph of CO₂ measured at Mauna Loa since 1958
      Bromothymol blue (BTB)
      an indicator: blue in fresh water, green, then yellow as CO₂ makes the water more acidic
      Ocean acidification
      the drop in ocean pH caused by CO₂ dissolving in seawater
      Airborne fraction
      the share of emitted CO₂ that stays in the air (about half)

      Differentiation

      Standards

      NGSS: MS-LS2-3 (cycling of matter among living and nonliving parts of an ecosystem), MS-LS1-6 (photosynthesis), MS-LS1-7 (respiration), MS-ESS3-5 (rise in global temperatures), HS-LS2-5 (photosynthesis and respiration in the carbon cycle), HS-ESS2-6 (quantitative model of carbon cycling), HS-ESS3-6 (human activity and Earth systems). Practices: analyzing data, developing and using models, constructing explanations (CER).

      18 · Common Misconceptions

      ❌ A plant’s mass comes mostly from the soil.
      ✅ Most of a plant’s dry mass is carbon, hydrogen and oxygen built from carbon dioxide in the air and water by photosynthesis. The soil supplies only small amounts of minerals. A big tree is mostly “solid air”.
      📖 Van Helmont’s willow experiment; NGSS MS-LS1-6; AAAS Project 2061 misconception items.
      ❌ Only animals respire; plants only photosynthesize.
      ✅ Plants respire all the time, day and night. In daylight they usually photosynthesize faster, so they take in CO₂ overall. In the dark, an Elodea alone turns BTB yellower (Mission 4, tube C).
      📖 OpenStax Biology 2e, ch. 7–8; classic BTB snail and Elodea lab.
      ❌ When fuel burns or a log rots, its carbon is destroyed.
      ✅ Atoms are not destroyed. Burning and decomposition turn the carbon in the fuel or the log into CO₂ gas, which goes into the air. The carbon just moves to a different store.
      📖 Driver et al. (1994), Making Sense of Secondary Science, ch. on matter cycles.
      ❌ Fossil fuels form quickly and are always being made, so they are renewable.
      ✅ Coal, oil and gas take millions of years to form from buried remains. We burn in one year fossil fuels that took hundreds of thousands of years or more to form, so on human timescales they are not renewable.
      📖 U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Nonrenewable energy sources”.
      ❌ CO₂ is rising because more people are breathing.
      ✅ About 8 billion people breathe out roughly 0.8 GtC a year, but that carbon came from food plants that took it from the air months earlier, so breathing adds no new carbon. The rise comes from burning fossil fuels and cutting forests: about 11.6 GtC of “new” carbon a year.
      📖 Global Carbon Budget 2025 (Friedlingstein et al.).
      ❌ The ocean soaks up CO₂ with no effect.
      ✅ The ocean has taken up about a quarter of all human CO₂ since 1850 (about 29 % in the last ten years), which slows warming, but dissolved CO₂ makes seawater more acidic: surface pH fell from about 8.2 to 8.1 since 1850, about 26 % more H⁺. That makes it harder for corals and shellfish to build shells.
      📖 IPCC AR6 WG1 ch. 5; NOAA PMEL Carbon Program, “Ocean acidification”.

      19 · FAQ

      What are the main processes of the carbon cycle?
      Photosynthesis takes carbon dioxide out of the air and turns it into glucose in plants and algae. Feeding passes that carbon along food chains to animals. Respiration by plants, animals and decomposers returns it to the air as CO₂. Death and waste move carbon into the soil, where decomposition releases it. Some remains are buried and become fossil fuels over millions of years (fossilization), and combustion releases that carbon again. The ocean also takes in and gives off CO₂.
      Which processes add carbon dioxide to the air, and which remove it?
      Respiration, decomposition, combustion and release from warm ocean water add CO₂ to the air. Photosynthesis and CO₂ dissolving into cold ocean water remove it. Feeding, death and fossilization only move carbon between other stores, so they do not change the air directly.
      Where is most of Earth’s carbon stored?
      Most carbon is locked in sedimentary rocks such as limestone: more than 60 million gigatonnes of carbon (GtC; 1 GtC = 1 billion metric tons). Of the stores that exchange carbon quickly, the deep ocean is by far the largest (about 37,000 GtC). Soils hold about 1,700 GtC, the air about 900, the surface ocean about 900 and all living plants about 450, so the air holds about twice as much carbon as all living plants.
      Do plants respire, or do they only photosynthesize?
      Plants do both. They respire all the time, day and night, releasing CO₂ just like animals. In daylight they usually photosynthesize faster than they respire, so overall they take CO₂ in. A classic lab shows it: an Elodea water plant alone in a sealed tube of bromothymol blue turns the BTB yellower in the dark, because with no light only respiration happens.
      What is the Keeling Curve and why does it zigzag?
      The Keeling Curve is the record of CO₂ measured on Mauna Loa in Hawaii since 1958. The yearly average rose from about 316 ppm in 1959 to 421 ppm in 2023. Each year it zigzags by about 6–7 ppm: CO₂ falls from May to October while plants in the Northern Hemisphere grow and photosynthesize, and rises in fall and winter when leaves drop and decomposers keep respiring. The north has more land and plants, so its seasons set the pattern.
      How do humans affect the carbon cycle?
      Mainly by burning fossil fuels and by cutting down forests: about 11.6 GtC a year in 2024 (fossil fuels about 10.3, land use about 1.3). Burning coal, oil and gas releases carbon that was stored for millions of years, and cutting forests means less photosynthesis. Plants and the ocean take up only about half of the extra CO₂, so the rest builds up in the air and warms the climate.
      Why does only about half of our CO₂ stay in the air?
      The ocean and land plants take up the rest. In the last ten years the ocean absorbed about 29 % of human CO₂ emissions and land plants about 21 %, so about half stayed in the atmosphere. These sinks pull harder when there is more CO₂ in the air, but warming and acidification can make them weaker in the future.
      Why does extra CO₂ stay in the atmosphere for so long?
      A pulse of extra CO₂ is not removed at one rate. Plants and the surface ocean take up part of it within a few decades, and mixing into the deep ocean removes more over several centuries. But about 20–25 % is still in the air after 1,000 years and is removed only over tens of thousands of years, as ocean carbonate chemistry and the weathering of rocks slowly catch up. That is why stopping emissions stops the rise but does not bring CO₂ back to 280 ppm for a very long time.
      Why is the ocean called both a carbon sink and a problem?
      It has absorbed about a quarter of all human CO₂ since 1850 (about 29 % in the last ten years), which slows warming. But the dissolved CO₂ forms carbonic acid: surface ocean pH has dropped from about 8.2 to 8.1 since 1850, which is about 26 % more H⁺ ions. Shell-building organisms (corals, pteropods, coccolithophores) find it harder to build calcium carbonate in more acidic water. So the ocean buys climate time at a cost to marine life.
      Is planting trees enough to fix this?
      Planting and protecting forests helps, but it is not enough on its own. Estimates of the extra carbon new forests could store are roughly 100–200 GtC over a century: about 10 to 20 years of today’s human emissions (about 11.6 GtC per year). The trees must also survive: fire, drought and pests can turn a forest from a sink into a source in one bad year. Cutting fossil-fuel emissions is the main lever.

      20 · References

      Friedlingstein, P. et al. (2023). Global Carbon Budget 2023. Earth System Science Data, 15, 5301–5369.
      IPCC, 2021. Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Working Group I contribution to the Sixth Assessment Report. Cambridge University Press.
      Archer, D. (2005). Fate of fossil fuel CO₂ in geologic time. JGR Oceans 110, C09S05.
      Sarmiento, J.L. & Gruber, N. (2006). Ocean Biogeochemical Dynamics. Princeton University Press.
      NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory. Mauna Loa CO₂ annual mean data (co2_annmean_mlo), Lan, X., Tans, P. & Thoning, K. Trends in globally-averaged CO₂ determined from NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory measurements. gml.noaa.gov/ccgg/trends.
      Friedlingstein, P. et al. (2025). Global Carbon Budget 2025. Earth System Science Data (fossil CO₂ 10.3 GtC in 2024; ocean and land sinks of the last decade).
      Canadell, J.G. et al. (2021). Global Carbon and other Biogeochemical Cycles and Feedbacks. In: IPCC AR6 WG1, Chapter 5, Figure 5.12 (global carbon cycle stores and fluxes).
      Archer, D. et al. (2009). Atmospheric lifetime of fossil fuel carbon dioxide. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, 37, 117–134.